The Secret of Swing

A new song in the style of a 1930s hot-jazz standard

by Elana Fremerman

NEXT PAGE
1 2 3
("Secret of Mine" transcription begins on page 2.)


Although I have played the violin since age five, it wasn't until I was 23 that I first heard "western swing" and "hot jazz," two kinds of music that changed my life. Today, those styles best define what my band the Hot Club of Cowtown plays. As a classically trained violinist, the fiddle tunes and jazz-fueled dance music of Bob Wills and his Texas Playboys were the last thing on my mind.

I grew up in Kansas City, Missouri, and as a child played in all the orchestras that I could—school, district, state, the Kansas City Youth Symphony—as well as playing chamber music and sometimes performing on the street with friends just for fun. When I went off to Barnard College in New York City in 1988, I continued taking violin and viola lessons at the Manhattan School of Music with Lucie Robert and Karen Ritscher. I spent summers at Meadowmount, Musicorda, and other chamber-music programs.

In 1992, after a summer at the American Conservatory at Fontainebleau in France, I went straight to North India, to a town called Brindavan, to study a style of North Indian classical music called dhrupad. That was the first time I started improvising, but I really didn't know what I was doing. My teacher was eccentric and very old-school: If I wanted to learn a rag that was only supposed to be played in the morning I had to get to his house before dawn so we could work on it. Learning this style of music meant learning how to improvise in a proscribed way. Often only certain notes in a specific order were allowed. Restraint was necessary to gradually build the music in volume and tempo. The idea of slowly insinuating the melody, hinting at it, and drawing it out subtly was all-important. I have since found that all of these ideas work well in swing improvisation.

East Meets West

After India I worked occasional summers as a horse wrangler in Clark, Colorado, playing fiddle in the ranch owner's band at night. We played in a barn and did a lot of traditional cowboy songs like "Don't Fence Me In," "I'm an Old Cowhand," and "Red River Valley." Most of the songs were in G, C, or D major and I would just play long, legato lines behind the singer. I didn't know much about improvisation—I just played notes that I thought sounded good.

It wasn't until I went back to New York and took lessons with violinist and arranger Marty Laster that I started to get an idea of what swing music improvising is. We would play very simple western swing songs like "Take Me Back to Tulsa" or "Bubbles in My Beer" and look at their chord structures. At first I couldn't even hear where the I chord went to the V chord, but we would chart out the chord structure (usually just four or five chords in the whole song) and Marty would have me write out solos using improvising techniques. These included playing a major seventh note over a chord, or using a lot of sixths (one of the brightening and elegant hallmark sounds of early swing), playing double-stops, or even taking time and sliding up to hold one note somewhere high on the fingerboard (as opposed to playing a lot of eighth-note runs or rapid, ornate flourishes) and doing it with absolute authority.

A book I discovered around 1994 entitled Western Swing Fiddle by Stacy Phillips (Oak Publications, reissued in 1997) was like my bible because it had a lot of melody and solo transcriptions of western swing recordings. Eventually I bought a few of those records and practiced playing along. That, for me, has proven to be the single best way to learn and be inspired. (For information on some of my favorite recordings, see "Hot Fiddle Favorites.")

In 1994, I met Whit Smith, now the guitar player in my band, and we began playing and learning western swing songs and fiddle tunes. We listened to recordings by such hot fiddlers as Stuff Smith, Joe Venuti, the Hot Club of France (with Stephane Grappelli and Django Reinhardt), Johnny Gimble of the Bob Wills band, Hugh and Karl Farr, and many others. As soon as I heard these recordings I knew that this style of music was the missing link. It was fiery and virtuosic and classy, had a danceable, driving rhythm, and was not at all hokey or campy. Stuff Smith, Venuti, Grappelli, and Bob Wills' fiddle players from the early 1940s all shared a kind of old-world sound that was a combination of romantic and raw, and always elegant.

What I like best about hot jazz, and about many of the western swing fiddle players from the 1920s through the '40s, is the unabashed emotion and spunk in their playing. It's not about being cool; it's about being hot. Joe Holley, one of my all-time favorites, played with Bob Wills in the 1940s. I love how he plays chirping, lilting, really manic lines behind the vocalist. And his solos just go all out. Check out "Chinatown My Chinatown" from The Tiffany Transcriptions. Stuff Smith, who was already playing and recording in the 1930s, also just goes bananas when he solos. A great example of his brilliant style is his live radio recording of the "Bugle Call Rag" from 1944, recorded on The Mad Genius of the Violin. His trademark is his use of parallel fifths, octaves, and driving rhythmic licks, very much like a horn player. I think if I played the horn I would start listening to a lot of Smith to hear how it ought to be done!

Secret of Mine

To give you a taste of my band's sound, I've transcribed the fiddle intro, the fiddle solo, and the fiddle-guitar duet, including the walking bass line beneath it, from our recorded version of a song I wrote called "Secret of Mine." (The written music begins on the next page.) I wanted to come up with a progression that all three of us in the band could solo over, at a fairly bright tempo, with chord changes that I knew we would like. I picked a common form in early pop tunes, the 32-bar form, but I added a turnaround at the end to give it some extra snap. The intro was definitely inspired by Venuti, whose use of harmonics is always beautiful and fresh. The parallel fifths are also Venuti-esque, though many of my favorite players like Gimble and Smith also throw them in to great effect.

The twin line between the guitar and fiddle was inspired by the Hot Club of France's recording of "Swanee," on which Reinhardt and Grappelli harmonize a very staccato version of the melody while the bassist (Louis Vola) plays (or walks) four notes to a bar beneath them. The bass walks lightly, playing a note on every beat (instead of slapping or playing on only the first and third beats of each bar). It's supposed to sound kind of like a whisper, like the bass is tiptoeing around.

For the melody, I took the rhythm from the classic hot-jazz standard song "Shine," which has been recorded by everyone from Louis Armstrong to Grappelli, and I wrote words with the same number of syllables. I wanted a melody that was kind of spare, without too many words. The turnaround at the end is very much like the endings on many Tin Pan Alley standards, including "After You've Gone," "Lover Come Back to Me," and so on.

For more information and transcriptions of other songs by the Hot Club of Cowtown, visit www.hotclubofcowtown.com.


HOT FIDDLE FAVORITES

Here are a few of my favorite recordings, featuring jazz and swing fiddlers and guitarists:

  • Oscar Alemán, Swing Guitar Masterpieces, 1938–1957 (Acoustic Disc ACD 29).
  • Django Reinhardt, Vol. 1, The First QHCF Recordings, 1934–1935 featuring Stephane Grappelly [sic] (JSP Records JSP CD 341).
  • Stuff Smith, The Mad Genius of the Violin, Vol. 1, 1936/1944 (Jazz Archives No. 108).
  • Joe Venuti, 1927 to 1934 Violin Jazz
  • (Yazoo 1062).
  • Bob Wills and His Texas Playboys The Tiffany Transcriptions, Vols. 1–10 (Kaleidoscope Records K6002; Rhino Records 71469–77).

NEXT PAGE
1 2 3

Photo by Señor MacGuire.

Excerpted from Strings magazine, November/December, No. 106.


 Return to Top